When Your Child Clings to One Parent: How Your Relationship Matters, an article by Carl Argent
When Your Child Clings to One Parent
How Your Relationship Matters
One parent feels rejected and the other cannot get a break. A child's preference can become an argument between the adults, and your relationship deserves attention too.

Look at what happens between all of you
When a child keeps asking for one parent, it’s worth considering the adults’ relationship as well as the child’s bond with each person. Children experience their parents together, too. How you support each other, disagree and share the care can affect what family life feels like.
A preference for one parent doesn’t tell us, on its own, that there is an attachment problem. It may reflect the routines your child knows, who has been available or what they need at that moment. We need to understand your particular family before drawing conclusions.
In relationship counselling, I help parents look at the tension that can develop around this: one feeling rejected, the other feeling that they have to do everything. It’s a relationship difficulty worth attending to in its own right.
Book a free relationship consultation
The pressure on both parents
Your child wants Mum to do bedtime again. If you are Mum, you may be exhausted and desperate for a break. If you are the other parent, being turned away can hurt, especially when you were trying to help. The resulting argument can leave both of you feeling that your partner has missed the point.
Where Mum has usually done the comforting or bedtime routine, asking for her may be familiar and reassuring. In another family it will be Dad, another parent or a different carer. This is about the care the child knows, rather than a rule about mothers or fathers.
It can be difficult to remember that when you feel rejected by your own child. You may start watching for evidence that they prefer your partner, or stop offering because another refusal feels too painful. Meanwhile, your partner sees you stepping back and feels even more alone with the work.
Your relationship is part of your child’s world
Attachment is often discussed as though everything happens between a child and their main carer. That relationship matters. Children can also have attachment relationships with several people, and their experience of each one sits within the family they live in.
You know how much harder it can be to respond patiently when you have just argued with your partner or feel criticised by them. Feeling supported changes what you have available to give. A child also hears the conversations between you and sees how you respond to each other.
What if a child’s attachment is shaped more by the relationship between their parents than by their relationship with their primary caregiver?
The research supports taking this wider family view. It doesn’t establish that the parents’ relationship matters more than the primary-caregiver bond. What it gives us is a reason to consider both. Looking at your relationship can help you think about the family as a whole, including how you support each other in caring for your child.
Book a free relationship consultation
How an arrangement becomes difficult to change
Consider this hypothetical bedtime. A child asks for Mum. Dad withdraws because he feels unwanted. Mum takes over because the child is upset, while resenting that she has another evening without a break. The next night begins with everyone expecting the same thing.
Both parents can then feel justified in their complaint. Dad thinks he is never given a chance. Mum thinks he gives up and leaves her to deal with it. Underneath the argument, there may be a need to feel trusted or a need for support that doesn’t disappear when the child protests.
We would also look at what is practical. Work hours, breastfeeding, disability, illness and other caring responsibilities affect who can do what. An apparently simple suggestion to share everything equally can ignore the life you actually have.
What we can work on as parents and partners
You can bring an ordinary example to a session: the bedtime, the handover or the moment when one of you took over. I’d ask what happened for each of you. What did you hear your partner saying about you? What did you need from them that you did not know how to ask for?
That gives us something more useful than deciding which parent should have tried harder. You can begin to understand the rejection, frustration or lack of confidence that is affecting how you respond. We can then discuss the support and responsibilities you are each asking the other to take on.
Your relationship also needs attention beyond getting the parenting tasks done. If every conversation concerns who is taking over, you may have lost the sense that your partner likes you, trusts you or wants time with you. We can talk about that loss alongside the daily arrangements.
Arguments about children often carry fears about being a good parent or being heard as a partner. My article on parenting disagreements looks at those concerns in more detail.
Changes parents have described to me
Parents in my relationship work have sometimes told me that their child starts approaching the parent they previously seemed less close to. They have described a child wanting to play, seeking comfort or feeling more comfortable spending time with that parent.
That is something parents have reported, rather than an outcome I can promise. One possibility is that a change between the adults allows a different experience to develop. A parent who feels supported may be more able to stay involved; the parent doing most of the care may feel less alone.
The aim is not to get your child to divide their affection fairly. We are looking at whether your family relationships can become safer, more dependable and less tense. Your child may also have needs or difficulties that require their own attention.
Before trying another bedtime arrangement
Talk away from your child, at a time when neither of you is in the middle of taking over. Ask what the usual exchange feels like for your partner. You might find that the person who looks irritated is feeling rejected, or that the person who keeps stepping in is worried that help will be withdrawn.
Then think about a small opportunity for the child and the other parent to enjoy time together. A familiar game, a story or a short outing may be easier than beginning with the most difficult bedtime. Keep it comfortable for your child. Withholding reassurance to force closeness makes them responsible for an adult problem.
These are opportunities to build familiarity, not tests your child needs to pass. A preference can change, and it can also persist while there is still a loving relationship with both parents.
When a child’s reluctance needs closer attention
If your child is frightened of a parent or there has been harm, take that seriously. Persistent distress needs to be understood in its own context. Working towards greater closeness is not a substitute for assessing what is happening and getting appropriate support.
Coercive control, intimidation or violence can also make joint relationship work unsuitable. Your safety and your child’s safety come first. You don’t have to remain a couple for the sake of the children. Where it’s safe, separating parents can get help with communication and boundaries across two homes.
Deciding what kind of support you need
If this has become an argument between you, relationship therapy gives us time to understand both sides and work on how you respond to each other. I see couples in Shoeburyness, Southend-on-Sea, and online across the UK. You can ask about the work in a free 30-minute consultation.
Book a free relationship consultation
You may instead want to focus on your own emotional responses as a parent. Through counselling for parents, we can look at how you recognise feelings, express them and respond when parenting touches a difficult part of your own experience. That is a separate starting point, and you can discuss it with me even if your partner doesn’t want to attend.
Book a free parenting consultation
The research behind the wider family perspective
Davies and colleagues (2002), Child emotional security and interparental conflict. Four studies supported the role of children’s emotional insecurity about parental conflict in explaining adjustment difficulties, including after accounting for parenting processes. This supports examining the wider family; it does not rank every parent–child bond against the adult relationship.
Neppl and colleagues (2019), Couple interaction and child social competence: The role of parenting and attachment. A longitudinal study of 209 families found associations between couple interactions, parenting and parent–child attachment. These associations do not show that couples therapy causes a particular attachment change.
Laurent, Kim and Capaldi (2008), Prospective effects of interparental conflict on child attachment security and the moderating role of parents’ romantic attachment. This study followed 80 heterosexual couples and their first-born children. Links between parental conflict and later attachment security varied with the parents’ characteristics.
Tomfohr-Madsen and colleagues (2020), Improved Child Mental Health Following Brief Relationship Enhancement and Co-Parenting Interventions During the Transition to Parenthood. Secondary analyses of a trial involving 90 opposite-sex couples found benefits in parent-reported infant outcomes. The intervention did not test whether children became closer to a less preferred parent or evaluate my therapy.
The two of you
as parents
Tell me about the moments when your child's preference becomes an argument between you. We can look at the care you are sharing and what each of you needs from your partner.
Book a free relationship consultation
Get to know yourself.
Find a step that fits.
Sometimes it helps to put words to what you bring, what matters and what feels difficult. These free questionnaires give you a personal PDF to reflect on, with no obligation to become a client.
Know your strengths
Recognise qualities you may overlook, see how you use them across your life and explore what helps you feel more like yourself.
Explore your strengths →Discover your values
Understand why some choices leave you torn. Put words to what matters and find a practical step towards the life you want.
Explore your values →Short ADHD screening
Put attention and organisation difficulties into words with nine questions. Get a summary of patterns worth discussing; this is not a diagnosis.
Try the nine questions →Want to connect the two? Values give you direction; strengths are qualities you could draw on along the way. Complete Strengths and Values with the same name and email for a combined report with personal reflection prompts and small experiments to try.
Strengths and Values reports wait for one hour so we can check for both. You can complete either on its own. Your information is stored securely; contact and mailing-list choices are optional.

